This week’s contributor is Kristen Swensson, one of the main writers behind Cheap Healthy Good. CHG maintains recipes can be all three and has the numbers to prove it, hence why it’s a clear favorite for the Mushroom Channel and the feelings seem to be mutual.
As young-ish Brooklynites who don’t host a lot of formal gatherings, my boyfriend and I rarely make appetizers. When we do, they generally consist of Triscuits and a plastic tub of hummus, served on a platter if we’re feeling extra fancy. Alas, we were forced to bring hors d’oeuvres to a friend’s house for the ultimate in football game days (We have a 27-inch Sharp. He has a 52-inch HDTV. We have no choice.) Since 95.7% of potential attendees are trying to eat healthier in the New Year, I wanted to make our offering a little leaner. It was time to test a new recipe.
My first inclination was to create something vegetable-based, as it would naturally keep calories down. The dish had to have a quick cooking time, too, and couldn’t be raw, since our host would already have a crudité platter. Having just received Cook’s Illustrated Best Light Recipes for Christmas, I started leafing through for ideas. See, Christopher Kimball & Company always know what’s best. They’re the Julie Andrews of cooking.
They had it right this time around, too. Right there, on page 23, was a recipe for Light Stuffed Mushrooms. The nice thing about mushrooms (which granted, you might know if you’re already locked into this website) is that they’re ridiculously low in fat and calories. Plus, their shape makes them perfect vessels for all kinds of tasty things: cheese, breadcrumbs, even small children if they’ll fall for it. Subsequently, they seemed like a logical choice for a game day offering.
To get started, all I needed was the mushrooms themselves. So, I set out to Key Food to procure two pounds of button-variety fungi. Happily, they were on sale for $3/pound. Even better, there was no line at the self-checkout. If you’ve ever been waited on by a 17-year-old New Yorker who’d rather text her ex-ex-ex-boyfriend than ring up your produce, you know this is a good thing.
At home, prep proved to be relatively easy, since the mushroom caps could roast while I sautéed the stuffing. Jamming the cheese mixture into the caps was another story, but somehow, everything ended up assembled. (I don’t know how. I might have blacked out.) Ten final minutes in the oven brought everything together, and my boyfriend and I tested ‘em the millisecond they emerged.
And? Victory. Savory and light, they had a subtle saltiness tempered by splashes of sherry and white wine vinegar. We polished off 15 that night without even coming up for air. (To be fair, it was our dinner.) For the party, I prepped everything except the final dusting of cheese, and then finished cooking in our friend’s oven.
Next time you’re made to make a finger food, try mushrooms. They’re good starting points for … well, a lot of things. Mostly, they’re just good.
P.S. For convenience, I recorded my price calculations below this recipe. Cook’s Illustrated kindly provided the nutritional information, so that’s noted as well.
Stuffed Mushrooms
Makes 30 mushrooms, or 10 servings of 3 mushrooms each
Adapted from Cook’s Illustrated Best Light Recipe
MUSHROOMS
- 30 (1 1/2- to 2-inch wide) mushroom caps, wiped clean (about 2 pounds)
- 1 tablespoon olive oil
- 3 medium garlic cloves, minced or pressed through a garlic press (about 1 tablespoon)
- 1/4 teaspoon salt
- Pinch ground black pepper
FILLING
- 1 teaspoon olive oil
- 2 large shallots, minced (about 1/2 cup)
- 1 medium garlic clove, minced or pressed through a garlic press (about 1 teaspoon)
- 12 ounces white mushrooms, wiped clean and chopped fine (about 2 cups – half of this will come from the mushroom stems)
- 1 tablespoon fresh minced thyme leaves
- Salt
- 2 tablespoons dry sherry
- 1 tablespoon white wine vinegar
- 1/2 cup fresh bread crumbs
- 1 ounce Parmesan cheese, grated (about 1/2 cup)
- Ground black pepper
1) Place an oven rack in the middle of the oven and preheat to 450ºF. Cover a cookie sheet with tin foil and spray with cooking spray. Toss mushroom caps, oil, garlic, salt, and pepper, together in a bowl, and then put the caps gill-side down on the cookie sheet. Roast until juices come out, about 18-20 minutes. Flip and keep roasting until juices are completely gone, and mushrooms are browned, another 10 minutes or so. Remove the pan from oven, and tilt to drain the extra juices.
2) While mushrooms are roasting, heat the oil in large pan over medium-high heat. Add the shallots and sauté until soft, about 2 minutes, stirring so they don’t become browned. Stir the garlic in and sauté another 30 seconds or so. Add chopped mushrooms, thyme, and 1/2 teaspoon salt and sauté, stirring frequently, until everything is pretty dry, about 6 minutes. Stir in the sherry and cook another 1 minute. Off heat, add vinegar, bread crumbs, 6 tablespoons Parmesan, and stir. Season the mixture to taste with salt and pepper.
3) Using a spoon or fork, place about 1 teaspoon of the mushroom mixture into each cap. Top each cap with a little of the remaining Parmesan. Bake at 450ºF until the cheese is browned and melted and everything is warm, 10 to 15 minutes. Serve straight from the oven.
Approximate Calories, Fat, and Price Per Serving
Ten servings: 60 calories, 3 g fat, $0.88
Each: 10 calories, 1 g fat, $0.29
Calculations
- 30 mushroom caps, plus 12 ounces chopped white mushrooms (about 2 pounds): $5.98
- 1 tablespoon plus 1 teaspoon olive oil: $0.14
- 4 cloves minced garlic: $0.16
- 2 large shallots, minced (about 1/2 cup): $0.50
- 1 tablespoon fresh minced thyme leaves: $0.33
- 2 tablespoons dry sherry: $0.11
- 1 tablespoon white wine vinegar: $0.08
- 1/2 cup fresh bread crumbs: $0.08
- 1 ounce Parmesan cheese, grated (about 1/2 cup): $1.36
- 1/4 teaspoon salt: $0.01
- Ground black pepper: $0.02
TOTAL: $8.77
PER SERVING (TOTAL/10): $0.88






g, 